Is Bigger Better?

I am always changing things around at my house. Sometimes I like the result, sometimes it goes back the same exact way it was! And then there are the rare times I can't decide......That's where you, dear reader come in. I need your opinion on whether or not bigger IS better. I'm talking tables, of course! Here is a corner of my living room with the table that WAS there (which incidentally, I found in an alley!)

 

I like it just fine, but in a fit of re-arranging, I ended up with this in it's place.......

Now I can't decide which one I like better! Is the bigger, darker and chunky table better (which, incidentally, I found on the side of the road with a sign taped to it 'For Sale $25' and a phone number.....I called) or is the round, lighter pedestal base table a better shape? Let me know what YOU think. Thanks for your input, and for stopping by...please consider becoming a follower!